Update example with SRP priority ceiling

This commit is contained in:
Nathan 2022-12-29 10:20:46 -06:00
parent 27d41c1a38
commit 80b81ef122
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG key ID: 72C032F07DBCF919

View file

@ -1,12 +1,17 @@
# Target Architecture # Target Architecture
While RTIC can currently target all Cortex-m devices there are some key architecure differences that While RTIC can currently target all Cortex-m devices there are some key architecure differences that
users should be aware of. Namely the absence of Base Priority Mask Register (`BASEPRI`) which lends itself exceptionally well to the hardware priority ceiling support used in RTIC, in the users should be aware of. Namely the absence of Base Priority Mask Register (`BASEPRI`) which lends
ARMv6-M and ARMv8-M-base architectures, which forces RTIC to use source masking instead. For each implementation of lock and a detailed commentary of pros and cons, see the implementation of [lock in src/export.rs][src_export]. itself exceptionally well to the hardware priority ceiling support used in RTIC, in the ARMv6-M and
ARMv8-M-base architectures, which forces RTIC to use source masking instead. For each implementation
of lock and a detailed commentary of pros and cons, see the implementation of
[lock in src/export.rs][src_export].
[src_export]: https://github.com/rtic-rs/cortex-m-rtic/blob/master/src/export.rs [src_export]: https://github.com/rtic-rs/cortex-m-rtic/blob/master/src/export.rs
These differences influence how critical sections are realized, but functionality should be the same except that ARMv6-M/ARMv8-M-base cannot have tasks with shared resources bound to exception handlers, as these cannot be masked in hardware. These differences influence how critical sections are realized, but functionality should be the same
except that ARMv6-M/ARMv8-M-base cannot have tasks with shared resources bound to exception
handlers, as these cannot be masked in hardware.
Table 1 below shows a list of Cortex-m processors and which type of critical section they employ. Table 1 below shows a list of Cortex-m processors and which type of critical section they employ.
@ -18,21 +23,20 @@ Table 1 below shows a list of Cortex-m processors and which type of critical sec
| Cortex-M0+ | ARMv6-M | | &#2713 | | Cortex-M0+ | ARMv6-M | | &#2713 |
| Cortex-M3 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | | | Cortex-M3 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | |
| Cortex-M4 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | | | Cortex-M4 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | |
| Cortex-M7 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | |
| Cortex-M23 | ARMv8-M-base | | &#2713 | | Cortex-M23 | ARMv8-M-base | | &#2713 |
| Cortex-M33 | ARMv8-M-main | &#2713 | | | Cortex-M33 | ARMv8-M-main | &#2713 | |
| Cortex-M7 | ARMv7-M | &#2713 | |
## Priority Ceiling ## Priority Ceiling
This implementation is covered in depth by Chapter 4.5 of this book. This implementation is covered in depth by the [Critical Sections][critical_sections] page of this book.
## Source Masking ## Source Masking
Without a `BASEPRI` register which allows for directly setting a priority ceiling in the Nested Without a `BASEPRI` register which allows for directly setting a priority ceiling in the Nested
Vectored Interrupt Controller (NVIC), RTIC must instead rely on disabling (masking) interrupts. Vectored Interrupt Controller (NVIC), RTIC must instead rely on disabling (masking) interrupts.
Consider Figure 1 below, showing two tasks A and B where A has higher priority but shares a resource
Consider Figure 1 below, with B.
showing two tasks A and B where A has higher priority but shares a resource with B.
#### *Figure 1: Shared Resources and Source Masking* #### *Figure 1: Shared Resources and Source Masking*
@ -50,15 +54,18 @@ showing two tasks A and B where A has higher priority but shares a resource with
t1 t2 t3 t4 t1 t2 t3 t4
``` ```
At time *t1*, task B locks the shared resource by selectively disabling all other tasks which share At time *t1*, task B locks the shared resource by selectively disabling (using the NVIC) all other
the resource using the NVIC. In effect this raises the virtual priority ceiling. Task A is one such tasks which have a priority equal to or less than any task which shares resouces with B. In effect
task that shares resources with task B. At time *t2*, task A is either spawned by task B or becomes this creates a virtual priority ceiling, miroring the `BASEPRI` approach described in the
pending through an interrupt condition, but does not yet preempt task B even though its priority is [Critical Sections][critical_Sections] page. Task A is one such task that shares resources with
greater. This is because the NVIC is preventing it from starting due to task A's source mask being task B. At time *t2*, task A is either spawned by task B or becomes pending through an interrupt
disabled. At time *t3*, task B releases the lock by re-enabling the tasks in the NVIC. Because condition, but does not yet preempt task B even though its priority is greater. This is because the
task A was pending and has a higher priority than task B, it immediately preempts task B and is NVIC is preventing it from starting due to task A being being disabled. At time *t3*, task B
free to use the shared resource without risk of data race conditions. At time *t4*, task A completes releases the lock by re-enabling the tasks in the NVIC. Because task A was pending and has a higher
and returns the execution context to B. priority than task B, it immediately preempts task B and is free to use the shared resource without
risk of data race conditions. At time *t4*, task A completes and returns the execution context to B.
Since source masking relies on use of the NVIC, core exception sources such as HardFault, SVCall, Since source masking relies on use of the NVIC, core exception sources such as HardFault, SVCall,
PendSV, and SysTick cannot share data with other tasks. PendSV, and SysTick cannot share data with other tasks.
[critical_sections]: https://github.com/rtic-rs/cortex-m-rtic/blob/master/book/en/src/internals/critical-sections.md